Famous among locals and loved by tourists, Anna Maria Island is home to some of the best dessert shops in South Florida. Whether you want unique baked goods or delicious ice cream, the local dessert places in Anna Maria Island have you covered. In sprinkles!
Where should you go when you want dessert on your next trip to Anna Maria Island? Check out our list of the best places to get dessert!
Local Dessert Places on Anna Maria Island
Hometown Desserts
507 Pine Avenue, Anna Maria – 941-896-3167
Hometown Desserts offers the types of desserts you would expect from a traditional cake shop. They have all the classics like chocolate cake and red velvet. You can also find options like chocolate Oreo cake, carrot cake, coconut cake, and more. This shop also takes custom orders. Beyond cakes, Hometown Desserts has an excellent selection of pies, cupcakes, cookies, and other baked goods.
Small Town Creamery
5404 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach – 941-213-9107
True to its name, Small Town Creamery is a real small-town ice cream shop. They make their ice cream in over fifty flavors. You can stick with familiar favorites like strawberry and chocolate or try some of their unique flavor creations. Like any good ice cream shop, they also have a variety of toppings you can put on your ice cream. Customers can also try various cones, milkshakes, and sundaes.
The Donut Experiment
210C Pine Avenue, Anna Maria – 941-896-3172
To enjoy The Donut Experiment, you don’t need to be a fan of donuts. You don’t get the standard donuts you’ll find at other shops. With The Donut Experiment, you get to create your custom donuts to enjoy. Customers can choose from different icings, toppings, sweet sauces, and more. They also have a list of the most popular donuts they sell.
Holy Cow Ice Cream
3234 East Bay Drive, Holmes Beach – 941-779-0690
Cool off with your choice of 36 flavors at Holy Cow Ice Cream. They have a great selection of homemade ice cream. This shop also offers a range of milkshakes and other frozen treats. You can also find dairy-free and sugar-free options at Holy Cow Ice Cream.
Island Scoops
103B Gulf Drive North, Bradenton Beach – 941-592-3866
Island Scoops offers one of the best ice shop experiences you will find. They have a great selection of flavors, and you can choose from an assortment of toppings for cones and sundaes. Beyond the frozen treats, they sell baked goods like cake, cookies, and brownies. This shop also offers options for curbside pickup and delivery.
With a vacation rental on Anna Maria Island, you can enjoy the best dessert shops in this island paradise.
Ask Billi
For anything and everything on Anna Maria Island, reach out to me by clicking here. I can get you where you want to be by buying, selling, or vacation rentals. We are experts in the local market for vacation home rentals. Please call if we can help you!
Thanks for visiting!
